'The Hunger Games: The Sunrise on the Reaping' review: An exhausting exercise in franchise preservation


Courtesy of Lionsgate
The sixth entry in the increasingly beleaguered “The Hunger Games” franchise, a series that continues to generate serious coin thanks to its rabid, dedicated fanbase, “Sunrise on the Reaping” finds author Suzanne Collins returning to the proverbial well once again, this time dredging up an expansive, occasionally tedious backstory for Haymitch Abernathy, the drunken curmudgeon played with such wonderful cynicism by Woody Harrelson in the original four films. As much as it’s a tale about his origins, it’s another examination of oppression, submission, and the inevitable revolt against a tyrannical system, themes that once gave this dystopian saga considerable urgency but have since been recycled ad nauseum. There’s only so much rebellion one franchise can stage before the revolution itself begins to feel like a routine obligation, though as long as the money keeps rolling in, artistic necessity seems to be of secondary concern.
Francis Lawrence’s adaptation of Collins’ bestselling 2025 novel, which was earmarked for the big screen almost as soon as the book was announced, marks the second prequel in three years, following 2023’s equally underwhelming “The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes.” That film attempted to recontextualize the origins of President Snow, the future architect of the barbaric annual tournament in which citizens, young and old, from Panem’s 12 districts are selected to slaughter one another until only one remains. There was something genuinely provocative about this premise when the franchise first emerged, particularly in its examination of violence as mass entertainment and the ease with which an authoritarian government could manipulate the public. But what was once a compelling dystopian nightmare has gradually become an exercise in filling in the blanks of a story that hardly needed further explanation.
Set 24 years before the events of the original films, “Sunrise on the Reaping” introduces newcomer Joseph Zada as a teenage Haymitch, who wastes little time dropping a rather groan-inducing bit of foreshadowing when he announces, “I don’t drink.” Get it? Because eventually he’ll become a bitter, emotionally repressed alcoholic! Such winks to the audience are practically baked into the film’s DNA, which spends an inordinate amount of time reminding us where these characters are headed rather than giving us compelling reasons to care about where they are now. Haymitch, meanwhile, is hopelessly devoted to his girlfriend, Lenore Dove Baird (Whitney Peak), with whom he spends his days smooching across the grassy plains of District 12, occasionally accompanied by frolicking geese. It’s a picturesque romance, though hardly one that establishes much beyond the obvious fact that these two young lovers are destined for tragedy.
The annual reaping, the ceremony in which tributes are selected to represent their districts, happens to fall on Haymitch’s birthday. Although his name isn’t initially drawn, he’s forcibly plucked from the crowd after intervening when armed Peacekeepers threaten Lenore. Presiding over this spectacle with unmitigated menace and glee is Drusilla Sickle (Glenn Close, enthusiastically hamming it up), whose exaggerated makeup and frozen expressions resemble an uncanny porcelain doll that’s undergone one too many Botox injections. Alongside her is Plutarch Heavensbee (Jesse Plemons, assuming the role originated by the late Philip Seymour Hoffman), an ambitious television producer whose responsibilities include manufacturing the emotional highs and lows of the Games while manipulating the footage to maintain the Capitol’s carefully constructed narrative.
When the tributes later watch footage of the reaping aboard a train, they’re astonished to discover that the broadcast has been doctored to conceal the government’s brutality. “That’s not what happened,” someone remarks, as though the idea of an oppressive regime falsifying public dissent should come as some extraordinary revelation. Hasn’t this franchise already spent several movies establishing precisely how the Capitol operates? The manipulation of televised images remains an interesting idea, particularly given how easily propaganda can be packaged as entertainment, but Lawrence and screenwriters Billy Ray and Michael Lesslie treat these familiar observations with a self-importance that the material can no longer sustain.
Within this world, the Hunger Games are essentially CBS’s “Survivor” with a significantly higher body count, where pageantry, audience engagement, and manufactured drama are every bit as important as the violence itself. This provides a fitting showcase for Kieran Culkin, who brings a variation of his trademark “Succession” schtick to Caesar Flickerman, the flamboyant television host previously portrayed by the wonderful Stanley Tucci. For the Capitol, death is merely another opportunity to boost ratings, and the entire apparatus exists to ensure the audience remains entertained.Which makes it rather ironic that “Sunrise on the Reaping” struggles to put on much of a show itself.
The film is so preoccupied with servicing its established mythology, offering cheeky callbacks, familiar faces, and subtle winks to its most devoted followers, that it frequently neglects the fundamental business of developing its own characters. Lawrence, now directing his fifth installment, seems to assume that recognition is a suitable substitute for characterization. We know these people, or at least we know who some of them will become, so apparently that familiarity is supposed to do much of the emotional heavy lifting. The problem is that knowing a character’s eventual fate doesn’t automatically make their present circumstances compelling, especially when the screenplay barely allows them to exist beyond their designated functions in the narrative.
Among Haymitch’s fellow District 12 tributes are Wyatt (Ben Wang), Louella (Molly McCann), and Maysilee (Mckenna Grace), none of whom are afforded much room to develop beyond a handful of distinguishing traits. They arrive, establish their place in the proceedings, and are promptly swept along by a movie that’s perpetually rushing toward its next major plot point. For a story whose central horror involves watching young people fight for their lives, it’s remarkable how little effort is made to ensure we become invested in those lives in the first place. Their potential deaths ought to carry an enormous emotional burden, yet the film treats so many of its supporting players as narrative accessories that their suffering rarely registers beyond the immediate shock of the violence.
That leaves Zada to shoulder much of the dramatic weight, and to his credit, the young actor demonstrates considerable potential. There’s an appealing sincerity to his performance, particularly as Haymitch’s initial optimism gradually gives way to rage, grief, and disillusionment. He’s tasked with navigating what may be the darkest emotional trajectory this franchise has attempted, though the screenplay rarely gives him the breathing room necessary to make that transformation feel entirely organic. He’s constantly reacting to another catastrophe, another betrayal, another death and while Zada handles these demands admirably, his performance is frequently undermined by a film more concerned with reaching the next development than allowing the previous one to resonate.
Once the story finally moves into the arena, where the 50th Hunger Games doubles the usual number of tributes to 48, Lawrence does manage to summon flashes of the visceral excitement that made the earlier installments so effective. There are moments of genuine tension amid the carnage, and the elaborate mechanisms of the competition still offer a certain morbid fascination. Yet even here, the spectacle feels strangely weightless because the people caught within it remain so thinly drawn. By the time the inevitable conclusion arrives, it feels as though we’ve barely spent any time in the arena at all. Usually, that’s a compliment to a movie’s pacing. Here, it’s an indication of how little dramatic impact the experience has managed to leave behind.
The central romance doesn’t fare much better. Haymitch’s relationship with Lenore Dove is clearly intended to provide the emotional foundation for his eventual descent into the bitter, broken man audiences already know, but there’s precious little chemistry or genuine spark between them. The screenplay repeatedly insists upon the importance of their bond without doing nearly enough to establish its depth, leaving their affection feeling more like a predetermined plot requirement than a relationship worth investing in. The same problem extends to the supporting characters whose eventual fates are supposed to devastate us. Some survive, others perish, and too often I found myself feeling remarkably little either way. That’s a fairly damning indictment of a movie built around the tragedy of innocent lives being sacrificed for public amusement.
Worse still, the film is visually inert, particularly compared to the striking spectacle of the earlier entries. Remember the enormous IMAX-sized scope when Katniss first entered the arena in “Catching Fire”? There was an overwhelming sense of scale and danger to those sequences, a feeling that this monstrous competition existed within a world much larger than its participants. “Sunrise on the Reaping” rarely captures that same grandeur, despite its ambitious production design and considerable resources. Perhaps some of that comes down to simple overexposure, as we’ve spent so much time wandering through Panem that its once-distinctive sights and sounds have lost their novelty. Even the procession of colorful personalities, from Close’s grotesquely theatrical Sickle to Billy Porter’s flamboyant stylist Magno Stift and Elle Fanning’s younger Effie Trinket, feels like an assortment of recycled eccentricities. They’re dressed to impress, certainly, but underneath the elaborate costumes and exaggerated mannerisms, many seem like pale imitations of characters we’ve encountered before.
At least the cast does what it can with the material. Plemons fares particularly well as the conflicted Plutarch, whose emerging rebellious instincts offer an intriguing contrast to his position within the Capitol’s machinery of propaganda. His understated performance lends the character a welcome degree of moral ambiguity, especially opposite Ralph Fiennes, who portrays President Snow with a subdued but unmistakably prickly menace. Fiennes understands that the character’s most intimidating quality isn’t his capacity for theatrical cruelty but the chilling composure with which he exercises power. Both actors bring a level of sophistication to their roles that the surrounding material doesn’t always deserve, while Zada’s increasingly tortured performance suggests a promising career beyond the franchise that has introduced him.
Still, there’s something deeply frustrating about watching talented performers work so hard to lend substance to a movie that feels fundamentally unnecessary. At 158 minutes, “Sunrise on the Reaping” is the longest installment in the franchise, yet its problem isn’t necessarily that it feels long. Quite the opposite. It moves briskly enough, but with so little room for its characters, relationships, or tragedies to register, the entire experience becomes strangely ephemeral. It’s a movie packed with incident but starved of consequence, one that repeatedly confuses the accumulation of plot with the development of genuine dramatic stakes. By the time the credits roll, there’s precious little to carry away beyond the recognition that we’ve been given another elaborate explanation for something we already understood.
And that’s ultimately the most dispiriting thing about “Sunrise on the Reaping.” For all its talk of resistance, manipulation, and the dangers of turning human suffering into a commercial spectacle, the film itself feels like another product rolling off the Capitol’s assembly line, meticulously engineered to satisfy an audience that will undoubtedly turn up regardless of whether there’s anything meaningful left to say. The irony is almost too perfect. A franchise built around condemning the exploitation of violence as entertainment has become increasingly dependent on repackaging its own familiar horrors for another round of box-office receipts. Collins may well have more stories to tell within this universe, but Lawrence’s latest offers little evidence that every untold chapter deserves a two-and-a-half-hour theatrical treatment. At some point, even the most lucrative franchise has to recognize the difference between having more history to explore and having an actual story worth telling.
The Capitol may never tire of staging another Hunger Games, but after six movies, I’m beginning to understand how the tributes feel. May the odds be ever in our favor.
Grade: C
THE HUNGER GAMES: SUNRISE ON THE REAPING is now playing in theaters.





Comments